This review assessed how the Department of Justice (the Department) has implemented and operated the Section 46A powers introduced into the Prisons Act 1981 in December 2020. The findings show that, while policies and procedures generally provide a sound framework for responding to suspected infectious disease exposure, gaps in staff training, record-keeping, authorisation processes and disclosure practices limit the Department’s ability to demonstrate consistent compliance with the Act and Regulations.
Three key areas evidence the need for stronger assurance, clearer practice, and improved oversight.
Prison officers had not been trained in the policies and procedures which support Section 46A powers
Following the amendments to the Prisons Act 1981, the Department updated a key policy document to provide guidance for the mandatory testing of prisoners for infectious diseases. This updated policy contained specific and descriptive instructions for custodial staff to follow when exercising Section 46A powers, which if followed, would ensure compliance with the legislation.
However, the Department had not taken sufficient steps to make custodial staff aware of the change in legislation, policy, or provided appropriate training to exercise Section 46A powers. Without sufficient awareness or training, there is a risk that custodial staff will not be compliant with the Act or the Regulations.
Management of suspected infectious disease transmission is partially effective
The Regulations specify the process to be followed when managing a suspected infectious disease transmission involving bodily fluid. This includes requirements for authorising the use of Section 46A powers, notifying the respective prisoner of all relevant actions and decisions, and how to appropriately manage disclosure of results following a blood sample test. A review of available evidence showed that overall, blood samples were collected from people in custody in a lawful and appropriate manner, and prisoner medical records were only accessed under the appropriate circumstances.
Prisoners’ medical information is appropriately accessed and disclosed in line with legislation
The legislation provides processes for reviewing prisoner medical records when managing suspected exposure to infectious diseases. Our review found access to, and review of, prisoner medical records were limited to appropriately authorised personnel and were completed in accordance with legislation.
The legislation describes in detail how test results are to be disclosed and identifies the individuals responsible for providing notification. The Superintendent is required to inform the affected prison officer of the test results, and a medical officer is responsible for informing the prisoner from whom the sample was taken.
We were unable to provide reasonable assurance these requirements were consistently met. The Department could not provide sufficient records demonstrating that test result notifications had occurred or evidence showing how the results were disclosed to the relevant individuals.